The applicability of general terms and conditions in the Netherlands
Any business owner who enters into a contract with another business will almost always encounter general terms and conditions. Suppliers operate under terms and conditions of sale or delivery, customers under terms and conditions of purchase, and in many sectors, industry-specific terms and conditions also apply. The content of these terms is crucial in the event of a dispute, as they set out the key agreements: who is liable for damage, when a delivery deadline is critical, how long the contract runs, and which court has jurisdiction.
Many business owners are familiar with the rules from their role as consumers. A subscription that is tacitly renewed after the initial period can, as a rule, be cancelled by a consumer on a monthly basis, and unreasonable terms in general terms and conditions are quickly rendered inapplicable. It is a costly misconception to assume that this protection also applies to businesses. In commercial contracts, the basic principle is that the parties are bound by their agreements. The protection consumers enjoy against certain unreasonable terms does not apply in the same way to businesses. A software contract, lease agreement or framework agreement for marketing services may therefore simply continue automatically if you miss the notice period. That is why it is not only the content of your contract that matters, but also the question of which general terms and conditions actually apply. A timely contract review prevents you from only discovering afterwards what obligations you have entered into.
This article deals with the applicability of general terms and conditions based on Dutch rules. Do you do business with foreign customers or suppliers? Then be sure to read Part 2: International contracts, general terms and conditions and the Vienna Sales Convention, coming soon.
The ‘battle of forms’: who wins?
In business dealings, each party wants its own terms and conditions to apply, which is only natural. Both parties want the most favourable terms possible for themselves. Purchasing terms therefore typically contain strict delivery deadlines and keep the seller’s liability as broad as possible. Supply terms do exactly the opposite: they apply flexible delivery deadlines and limit the seller’s liability as much as possible. When the supplier refers to its terms of delivery in its quotation and the customer refers to its terms and conditions of purchase in its order or order confirmation, two sets of terms and conditions clash. This is known as the ‘battle of forms’.
Practical experience shows that, when concluding a contract, the parties remarkably often pay scant attention to this issue. It only becomes relevant when something goes wrong: a late delivery, a defective product or an unpaid invoice. At that point, the outcome of the commercial dispute often depends on which terms and conditions apply. The ‘battle of forms’ is crucial in this regard.
The ‘first shot rule’: first come, first served…
Under Dutch law, the party that first refers to its general terms and conditions has a significant advantage. If the other party subsequently presents its own terms and conditions, that second reference is ineffective unless it expressly rejects the first set of terms. This rule is known as the first shot rule (Section 6:225(3) of the Dutch Civil Code).
For businesses, the practical lesson is:
– Refer to your own general terms and conditions as early as possible;
– Preferably include a reference in the quotation, proposal, order confirmation or order itself;
– Do not wait until the invoice. A reference that only appears after the contract has been concluded is, as a rule, too late to make your terms and conditions part of the contract.
Furthermore, ensure that the reference is clear. A sentence in the main text of your quotation carries more weight than an inconspicuous footnote. Send the terms and conditions along with the document or make them available digitally in a way that allows the other party to save them and refer to them later.
Effectively rejecting general terms and conditions
If you wish to prevent the other party’s general terms and conditions from applying, it is not enough simply to state your own terms and conditions. You must expressly reject the other party’s terms and conditions. Here too, a clear rejection is advisable. A rejection that is hidden within your own general terms and conditions or at the bottom of your letterhead is risky. You should therefore include the rejection in the main body of your response, in the same place where you refer to your own terms and conditions. A clear way to phrase this is:
“We hereby expressly reject the general terms and conditions of [name of the other party] and declare our own general terms and conditions to apply.”
Please note: this does not always settle the matter. If you accept the other party’s offer but, in doing so, reject their terms and conditions and put forward your own, your response may be regarded as a new offer (Section 6:225(1) of the Dutch Civil Code). This does not mean that your terms and conditions apply immediately. The question then is whether the other party accepts that new offer. This may also be indicated by their conduct, for example, if they proceed to supply, manufacture or pay without protest.
What if both parties continue to reject each other’s terms?
Sometimes both parties expressly reject each other’s terms and conditions. In such cases, the ‘first shot rule’ no longer provides a solution, as each deviating response is again deemed to be a new offer and a rejection of the previous one. It is then not immediately clear whether the contract is concluded under the supplier’s terms and conditions, under those of the customer, or without any general terms and conditions. The outcome depends on the sequence of correspondence, the precise wording and the subsequent conduct of the parties.
This is precisely why it is wise to settle the matter before performance takes place. Confirm in writing which terms and conditions apply before you commence delivery or make payment. This prevents you from only discovering, when faced with a claim for damages or an unpaid invoice, that your limitation of liability, retention of title or choice of forum is not as secure as you thought.
Providing a copy remains a strict requirement
Even if your general terms and conditions have been declared applicable, you must give the other party a reasonable opportunity to familiarise themselves with their content (Section 6:234 of the Dutch Civil Code). The safest approach is to send your terms and conditions before or at the time of concluding the contract, for example as a PDF attached to the quotation or order confirmation. Electronic provision is also often possible, provided the other party can save the terms and conditions and consult them later. If the contract is not concluded electronically, the other party’s express consent is required for this.
If you fail to do so, the other party may attempt to set aside provisions in your terms and conditions. Setting aside such provisions does not automatically mean that the other party’s terms and conditions will apply instead. In practice, the result may be that neither set of general terms and conditions applies and that you are left to rely on the law. For a business owner relying on a limitation of liability, this can be a costly risk.
Include key provisions in the contract
General terms and conditions are useful, but do not let your most important protection depend entirely on them. Provisions regarding liability, retention of title, payment, termination, choice of law and choice of forum often deserve to be included in the contract itself. Should a dispute arise later regarding the applicability of your general terms and conditions, you will then have an additional safety net.
Do you want to improve your contract process? Then ensure that quotations, order confirmations, email templates and the digital ordering process all follow the same guidelines. Make reference to them early on, include the terms and conditions, check the other party’s documents and respond immediately to any deviating terms.
Having your general terms and conditions reviewed
Using general terms and conditions is not merely a formality. It determines which risks you bear and which agreements you can enforce. Is there a business contract on the table, has your company been using the same terms and conditions for years, or has a dispute arisen regarding delivery, payment or liability? If so, please contact our corporate law solicitors straight away for a contract review.
Frequently asked questions about general terms and conditions in the Netherlands
What is a ‘battle of forms’?
A ‘battle of forms’ arises when both parties to an agreement refer to their own general terms and conditions.
Which general terms and conditions apply under Dutch law?
In principle, the party that refers to its terms and conditions first is in a stronger position. The second reference is ineffective unless the second party expressly rejects the first set of terms and conditions.
Is a reference on the invoice sufficient?
Usually not. General terms and conditions must be addressed before or at the time the contract is concluded. An initial reference on the invoice is generally too late.
How do I reject the other party’s general terms and conditions?
Do so in writing and clearly in the main text of your response. Name the other party, expressly reject their terms and conditions, and declare your own terms and conditions to apply.
Do I need to send my general terms and conditions along with my correspondence?
Yes, that is the safest approach. Send the terms and conditions before or at the time the contract is concluded, preferably as a downloadable attachment.
When should I have my general terms and conditions checked?
Have your terms and conditions checked before you use them, before you sign an important contract, or as soon as a dispute arises regarding payment, delivery, liability or termination.