From now on, banks must first reimburse victims of fraud, according to the Court of Justice of the European Union
On 15 October 2026, the Court of Justice of the European Union (hereinafter: CJEU) handed down a landmark ruling concerning bank fraud. Victims now enjoy better protection against bank fraud, even if the bank itself considers them to have been negligent.
The case in brief
The ruling by the CJEU was prompted by a case in Poland. In this case, a woman had received a link online that appeared somewhat credible. As you may have guessed, this link was intended for something else entirely and led to a fake website that resembled that of her bank. Using the information the woman entered on this site, the fraudster managed to withdraw €705 from her bank account. After the woman discovered this, she reported it to her bank and the police. As, according to the bank, she had acted with gross negligence, the bank argued that she herself was responsible for the loss suffered.
The woman, who was not prepared to accept this, took the matter to the Polish courts. The court subsequently referred questions to the CJEU for a preliminary ruling on the bank’s obligation to refund unauthorised payments.
Refund first, assess later
The court ruled that, in principle, the bank must refund such an unauthorised payment immediately. This must take place no later than the end of the next working day after the unauthorised payment has been identified. This applies regardless of whether the bank considers that the customer acted negligently in relation to this unauthorised payment.
However, Article 73(1) of the European Payment Services Directive (PSD2) does provide an exception for banks under European legislation. Under this article, banks may still defer payments where there are reasonable grounds to believe that the customer is committing fraud themselves, provided these grounds are reported to the competent national authority.
However, this ruling does not mean that customers are always definitively entitled to compensation under these circumstances. As soon as the bank can subsequently demonstrate that the customer failed to fulfil his or her obligations either intentionally or through gross negligence, the bank may still recover the loss from the customer.
What does this mean for you?
This ruling places greater responsibility on the bank. Banks can no longer refuse to refund simply by citing negligence. As a result, the consumer is better protected and, now that the bank must in principle refund the money first, it is less likely that someone will find themselves in immediate financial difficulties following a scam.
It is important to note that not every form of banking fraud automatically entitles the victim to a refund. This ruling relates to unauthorised payments, which does not apply to payments made by the victim themselves. As these are carried out by the victim themselves, they are deemed to be authorised.
Although this ruling by the CJEU offers consumers better protection, it unfortunately does not reduce the degree of caution with which one must act. As it may still be determined retrospectively that a victim has acted with negligence, you ultimately face the same risks as before.
Conclusion
Although this ruling provides an answer to the question of how we can better protect consumers against this form of fraud, it remains to be seen whether it is a reasonable answer. After all, this shifts part of the responsibility onto the bank, whilst the bank – apart from providing up-to-date information – has little control over whether people fall for this sort of fraud or not. Furthermore, apart from the money the bank is required to repay immediately, the bank will also incur high costs in adapting its policies to this new ruling.
Questions?
Do you have any questions regarding this article? Our solicitors are on hand to advise you! Please contact one of our solicitors via email, by telephone or fill in the contact form for a no-obligation initial consultation. We’d be happy to discuss this with you.
About the author
Mignon de Vries
Intellectual property, Corporate Law & Disputes regulation and litigation