An Amsterdam tenant of a social housing flat, costing 600 euros a month, sublet it for 2,000 euros a month and has now been evicted from the property by the court

Earlier this year, we wrote about a tenant of a social housing flat who turned out to own seven owner-occupied properties and was evicted from his social housing flat by the court.

Today’s article also features a tenant of a social housing flat whose tenancy agreement has been terminated by the housing association. This is evident from a recent judgement by the Amsterdam Magistrates’ Court dated 20 October 2026. The housing association Stadgenoot was found to be entirely in the right. The rental agreement was terminated and the tenant must vacate the property.

What happened?

The tenant had been renting a two-room flat of approximately 51 square metres in Amsterdam since 2010. The flat consisted of one bedroom measuring 14.5 m² and one living room measuring 17.11 m². He paid a monthly rent of €616.76.

In June 2025, the tenant entered into a so-called subletting agreement with a third party for a period of one year. Under that agreement, the subtenant paid €2,000 per month, an amount well above the rent the tenant himself paid to the housing association. A month later, another person moved in with the subtenant.

Stadgenoot received a report that the property was being sublet and that the tenant was not living there themselves. During a home visit in August 2025, Stadgenoot staff found only the two subtenants present. The housing association then asked the tenant to terminate the tenancy. When he refused, Stadgenoot took the matter to the small claims court. It sought the termination of the tenancy agreement, eviction, payment of the rent arrears and the surrender of the profit made from the subletting.

A striking detail: the tenant himself had previously brought summary proceedings against his subtenant in an attempt to have him evicted from the property. That claim was dismissed, as the court had already ruled at that time that the ‘hospita’ arrangement was not sufficiently plausible and that only the subtenants were living in the property.

Subletting without permission is in itself a breach of contract

The basic principle under the law is that a tenant of a property may sublet part of it provided they continue to live there themselves. However, this rule is a matter of statutory law. Landlords are therefore permitted to deviate from it in the tenancy agreement. Stadgenoot had done just that. The tenancy agreement stipulated that the tenant must use the property as their main residence and that subletting, including the letting of rooms, was prohibited without written consent.

The magistrates’ court therefore ruled that the tenant had already breached the tenancy agreement simply by entering into the room-sharing agreement. Whether the arrangement actually constituted room-sharing was, in fact, no longer relevant to that finding.

Tip for landlords: Clearly stipulate in your tenancy agreement and general terms and conditions that the tenant must have their main residence there and that subletting in any form whatsoever, including letting out rooms, is only permitted with your written consent. This will help you avoid disputes later on.

Why the judge did not accept the ‘hospita’ arrangement

In a ‘hospita’ tenancy, the occupier lets out a room in their own home whilst continuing to live there themselves. The tenant claimed that this was the case here. The magistrates’ court did not accept this, for several reasons.

The ‘hospita’ tenancy agreement did not specify which room was being let. It referred only to ‘the let property’, meaning the entire home. Furthermore, the judge found it implausible that the tenant would have slept in the 17 m² living room for a whole year, whilst the subtenants used the only bedroom. The claim that it had been agreed verbally that the sublet would last only three months was also not found to be plausible. The contract ran for a year and the subtenants ultimately lived there for around eight months.

Principal residence: what must a tenant be able to prove?

The tenant stated that he had lived in the property continuously. He claimed that, after a holiday, he was unable to return because the subtenants had withheld the key. The judge was not convinced by this explanation either.

Before the subtenants left on 1 February 2026, they sent photographs of the property to the housing association. These showed only a few of the tenant’s non-personal belongings, such as a bed, a sofa and a washing machine. According to the magistrate’s court, this is insufficient to constitute living in a property: kitchen fittings and bed linen were missing. Furthermore, there was no personal décor whatsoever, such as private post, photographs and similar personal items. The tenant argued that the photographs gave a distorted picture and that his belongings had been deliberately removed. However, he did not substantiate this, for example with older photographs.

In addition, according to the Basic Register of Persons (BRP), many other people had been registered at the address over the years, some for more than five years. The judge found it difficult to reconcile the explanation that these were friends and family staying temporarily with such long periods of registration. The judge concluded that the tenant had not demonstrated that he had his main residence in the property either before or during the subletting period.

Serious breach: termination and eviction

Not every breach justifies the termination of a tenancy agreement. In the case of a minor breach, the judge may dismiss the claim. The tenant also invoked this argument: he expressed regret, the subletting had since ceased and, in his view, there had never been any intention to make a profit.

The magistrates’ court saw things differently. The property in question was a scarce social housing flat in Amsterdam. As a recognised body under the Housing Act, a housing association has a compelling interest in the fair allocation of social housing. By subletting, the tenant had circumvented that system. Furthermore, the judge regarded the fact that he had made a profit as a serious offence. The fact that the subletting had ceased did not undo the past breach.

Profit from subletting must be handed over

For landlords, the financial settlement is of particular interest. Stadgenoot claimed, pursuant to Article 6:104 of the Civil Code, the surrender of the profit the tenant had made from the subletting. Under that article, the court may assess the landlord’s loss as the profit the tenant obtained through his breach.

The tenant disputed the amount of the profit, but not the fact that he had made a profit. As neither party had submitted documentary evidence regarding the exact amount, the magistrate assessed the profit herself. She agreed with Stadgenoot’s calculation, which she found plausible and logical.

Tip for landlords: In cases of illegal subletting, seek not only termination of the tenancy and eviction, but also the surrender of profits. Support your calculation as concretely as possible, for example with the subletting agreement, messages or proof of payment. A clear and logical calculation increases the likelihood that the court will accept it.

Finally

Are you, as a landlord, housing association or property developer, dealing with a suspected case of illegal subletting? Or are you a tenant accused of not having your main residence in your property? Our tenancy law solicitors advise and litigate daily on subletting, letting to lodgers, termination of tenancy agreements and eviction. Please feel free to contact us for an initial assessment of your situation.


About the author

Koen Wanders

Mergers and acquisition, Corporate Law & Real Estate law